Legal news

Bad news for men with long hair
In Dansie v Metropolitan Police, the EAT decided that requiring a male employee to cut his shoulder-length hair did not constitute unlawful sex discrimination or sexual harassment simply because in similar circumstances a female employee would not have been required to cut her hair, as long as the employer’s overall dress code was "equally balanced between the sexes".

The Police Dress Code Policy stated, as one of its objectives: "The standard of dress should be smart, fit for the purpose and portray a favourable impression of the service." Separate Manager's guidance on this Policy stated that "Hair must be neat, not allowed to cover the ears and...worn above the collar. For safety reasons, ponytails are not permitted and long hair must be neatly and securely fastened up and worn relatively close to the head."

The employee turned up to a police training session with shoulder length hair slicked back on his head and tied in a bun on the back of his head. Prior to attending he had enquired and been told that his hair would comply with the Police Dress Code Policy. At the training session he was told to get a hair cut or face disciplinary action. He complied and then sued for sex discrimination on the basis that a female recruit in similar circumstances would not have been required to cut her hair.

The EAT agreed with the Tribunal that there had been no less favourable treatment on the basis that a female comparator who failed to comply with a gender neutral dress/appearance code would have been treated in the same way as the Claimant; i.e. she would have been required to comply with the Code as it affected her in the same way as the Claimant was required to comply with the Code as it affected him. Having found that the Policy was equally balanced between the sexes, the Tribunal's decision to dismiss the sex discrimination claims was sound.

 

Other news
  • Gender equality - women ski jumpers left out in the cold, again...read more
  • Sick whilst on holiday? Have another one on your employer!...read more
  • Constructive dismissal - What’s good for the goose, is good for the gander...read more
  • Viva variation clauses...read more
 
Forthcoming key employment legislation
  • February 2010
    Reduction in maximum unfair dismissal compensatory award ...read more
  • April 2010
    Extension of SMP postponed...read more
    Additional paternity leave...read more
    Right to request time off for training...read more
  • October 2010
    Equality Bill...read more
 
News from M&A Solicitors
  • M&A Solicitors offers clients the largest Welsh dedicated public sector team...read more
  • M&A Finalist at Welsh Women Mean Business Awards 2010...read more
  • George Osbourne visits M&A's offices...read more
Future seminars: Q1
The Equality Bill
29 April 2010
Venue: tbc
 
Useful links
M&A Solicitors LLP
Midas People Management LLP

 
Contact us
For further information on any employment issues, please contact James Moss, Head of Employment, on:

029 2067 4416
jmoss@manda.uk.com


Read James' profile
 
M&A Solicitors LLP
M&A Solicitors LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in Wales (registered number OC310274) and is regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority. A list of the members, all of whom are solicitors, may be inspected at our registered office: 3 Assembly Square, Britannia Quay, Cardiff Bay, Cardiff CF10 4PL.
 
Disclaimer
This e-Newsletter is intended to provide general information about legal topics. Nothing in this e-Newsletter, or in the documents available through it, is intended to provide legal advice. You should not rely on any information contained in this e-Newsletter, or in the documents available through it, as if it were legal advice. M&A Solicitors LLP is not responsible for the operation or content of any external website or hyperlink referred to in this e-Newsletter.
 
If you're having difficulty viewing this email, click here. To unsubscribe click here.